AICF’s Internal Turmoil: Two Veteran Chess Players Move Madras High Court, Seek Appointment of Administrator
Fed up with the strange developments in the All India Chess Federation (AICF) — two top officials fighting and calling three Special General Body Meetings to be held within a gap of two or three days, non-submission of audited accounts, and other issues — two veteran chess players have approached the Madras High Court seeking the appointment of an Administrator to restore normalcy in the Federation.
The Madras High Court, on November 13, 2026, ordered: “Considering the nature of the relief prayed for, none of the decisions that was taken in the meetings which has already been conducted on 12.11.2026 and the meetings that are going to be conducted on 14.11.2026 and on 17.11.2026 shall be implemented, except on approval / further orders from this Court.”
“With regard to the appointment of an independent administrator and the prayer to restrain respondents 2 to 4 (AICF, Nitin Narang, President and Dev A Patel, Secretary) from acting as Executive Council members, this Court will consider the grant of interim orders after hearing the respondents. Issue notice to the respondents returnable by 11.12.2026. Private notice is also permitted,” the High Court ordered.
The two senior chess players who have approached the High Court are Arvind Kumar Sinha from Bihar and Vijay Gopalrao Deshpande from Maharashtra.
“We have been friends for a long time. We are not happy with the happenings in AICF and hence filed the case,” Deshpande told this correspondent.
Explaining the reason for seeking the appointment of an Independent Administrator for the AICF, Deshpande, who had captained the Marathwada University chess team during his college days, said: “The President and the Secretary are not in talking terms it seems. The audited accounts for AICF has not been submitted. So an Independent Administrator is needed to set things right at the earliest.”
The petitioners’ demand for an independent Administrator represents a serious escalation of the crisis in the country’s chess administration. If appointed, the Administrator could oversee the Federation’s affairs and address concerns relating to its administration, financial disclosures and functioning until normalcy is restored, subject to the directions of the Court.
The AICF website makes available annual audited accounts only up to 2022-23, according to the records presently available there.
Further, chess circles are also agitated over the alleged payment of more than Rs. 88.79 lakh as legal fees to a law firm from funds contributed by players under different heads.
The Secretary’s November 14 Ahmedabad meeting agenda itself includes a discussion on the Federation’s books of accounts, audit, financial reports and statements.
According to officials, the High Court has not prohibited the holding of the Special General Body Meetings, but has restrained the implementation of decisions taken at these meetings without the Court’s sanction.
Novelty and out-of-the-book moves
In chess, a new move is called a novelty. The moves made by AICF President Narang and Secretary Patel are not only novelties but also out-of-the-book moves — in chess, this means playing a move that is not listed in the books; in administration, it means going beyond the rules.
The novelty lies in calling three Special General Body Meetings within a gap of two or three days, with one of the meetings being convened at barely a day’s notice. Narang had called the November 12 meeting, to be held virtually, on November 11.
According to chess administrators, Patel, who had called the November 14 meeting in Ahmedabad had conveyed his inability to attend it.
“This shows his lack of interest in AICF,” a top official of a State Chess Association told this writer, preferring anonymity for himself and his state.
It is not clear whether the meeting was held and business was transacted.
Some officials said the meeting was held with officials from about 10 state associations were in attendance and another said officials from 27 affiliates attended.
According to chess officials, the November 17 meeting to be held in Chandigarh will be crucial, as a large number of officials from state associations are expected to attend.
It was Narang who had first called the Special General Body Meeting for November 17 to decide on amendments to the AICF Constitution, which would alter its basic structure.
The main amendment proposed by Narang was the removal of the elected Secretary/Secretary General from the list of office-bearers and its replacement with a full-time salaried CEO, designated as “CEO/Secretary General”.
The CEO will head the administration and manage the day-to-day affairs of the Federation, including the Secretariat, staff, national championships, selections, FIDE registrations, ratings, transfers, and the administration of arbiters and trainers.
The Executive Committee will appoint the CEO on the recommendation of a three-member search committee comprising the President, Treasurer and one Sportsperson of Merit (SOM) representative. The Executive Committee will also determine the CEO’s contractual terms, remuneration and financial limits, and can remove the CEO in accordance with the contract.
On the other hand, the amendments proposed for the meeting called by the Secretary, following a requisition by some state associations, include retaining an elected Secretary as an office-bearer and an important administrative functionary. The proposal also retains four Vice-Presidents and four Joint Secretaries, alongside the President and Treasurer.
It envisages a five-member Emergency Committee comprising the President, Secretary, Treasurer, the seniormost Vice-President and the seniormost Joint Secretary. This provides for a collective mechanism to deal with emergencies, with the action taken to be reported to the appropriate AICF body for ratification.
Narang on Nov 13, to counter the meeting called by the Patel, had called another general body meeting for Nov 14.
In the meantime, strangely the Appellate Authority of AICF had ordered deferment of the three general body meeting.
A former AICF official told this writer that the Appellate Authority does not have the power to issue any such orders against a duly convened general body meeting.
It is also not known who has approached the Appellate Authority on the issue.
Thus, what began as a disagreement between the President and Secretary over the administration of the AICF has now reached the courts.
With two rival sets of constitutional amendments on the table and an independent Administrator being sought, the future administrative structure of Indian chess is now as much a matter for the courts as it is for the Federation’s General Body.
(Venkatachari Jagannathan can be reached at venkatacharijagannathan@gmail.
